Before and After: Motherhood, Beauty and the Bollywood Body

How Hindi cinema and its audiences police the maternal body, from Aishwarya Rai Bachchan to Katrina Kaif
Abstract: Every few years, a new mother in Hindi cinema is photographed, compared with her earlier self and found wanting. This article traces that “before and after” habit from the trolling of Aishwarya Rai Bachchan in 2012 to the scrutiny of Katrina Kaif in 2026, with Bipasha Basu’s career as one thread among several. Drawing on Barbara Creed’s monstrous-feminine and Julia Kristeva’s abjection, it argues that screen and society share one anxiety: the maternal body is meant to be desirable and unchanged, and the moment it visibly changes it becomes an object of disgust. It ends with women who are now naming that double standard themselves.
When I was growing up, my mother, a teacher, was fiercely committed to her fitness. She had an unfettered josh, the kind that lets a working woman carve out half an hour for herself. After a day of moulding the minds of bickering schoolchildren, she would let off steam by putting on a workout DVD, dumbbells in hand. This was around 2014, and the discs were bought from a shop in our Fauji Colony in Colaba. At 5 pm every day, my thirteen-year-old self and my mum would break a leg (sometimes quite literally) following the instructor on screen.
I did not think about it then, but the body we were copying belonged to a woman who had spent her career being looked at. The body that mattered most in that living room was my mother’s, tired, capable and entirely her own. Years later, it is the gap between those two bodies, the one on the screen and the one in the room, that I find myself writing about.

The “before and after” machine
In November 2011, Aishwarya Rai Bachchan gave birth to her daughter, Aaradhya. By the following May, before she had even walked the red carpet at Cannes, the verdict was in. A video titled “Aishwarya’s shocking weight gain” juxtaposed her old photographs with new ones and added elephant sound effects. It was reportedly watched more than half a million times [1]. The film scholar Rachel Dwyer suggested that the obsession was less an Indian tradition than a global habit of pulling stars down: women who lose weight are congratulated, and those who do not are said to be letting themselves go [2]. Aishwarya’s own reply was calm. She was a mother, she said, this had happened to her, and that was fine [3].
Fourteen years later, the script has barely changed. Katrina Kaif welcomed her son Vihaan in November 2025 and largely stayed out of public view. Kaif eventually attended the Ambani family’s Ganesh Chaturthi celebrations, and later, a prayer meeting for filmmaker Kuku Kohli. Reactions on social media declared her finished, with her before-and-after pictures stacked up like exhibits in something one report likened to a courtroom. [4][5]. Similarly, Bipasha Basu, who had her daughter Devi in November 2022, described in her recent ELLE India cover interview that women are expected magically to return to the shape of their twenties after giving birth, even in their forties, and that those who fail to “bounce back” are trolled mercilessly [6].
Three actresses, three decades of the same photograph. What links them is not vanity, theirs or ours, but a belief that the celebrity body is public property. In this logic, a woman who has just given birth is not recovering, nursing or sleeping badly. She is a product that has been returned to the shelf with a defect.
The maternal body as monster
It is tempting to treat this as simple cruelty, but film theory suggests it is a more structured anxiety. In The Monstrous-Feminine, Barbara Creed argued that horror does not merely fear women; it is organised around fears of the female body, and above all the maternal body [7]. Drawing on Julia Kristeva’s idea of abjection, she showed that horror emerges when the boundaries that keep us stable (inside and outside, self and other, clean and unclean) begin to collapse [8]. Pregnancy is a collapse of exactly this kind. One body contains another, swells, leaks and changes. Cultures that revere the mother also tend to be unsettled by what motherhood does to a woman’s body.

Hindi cinema has long staged this unease. Bipasha Basu, nicknamed Bollywood’s “Horror Queen” after Raaz, Raaz 3, Creature 3D and Alone, is a useful case because her films cover two figures Creed describes: the possessed woman, whose body is invaded by something that must be driven out (Raaz), and the femme fatale, whose desire is the danger and who the story must punish (Jism). In both, her sensuality is never removed. It becomes part of the threat.
Set beside the trolling, the pattern is hard to miss. On screen, the woman’s body is allowed to be either an object of desire or a vessel for horror, but never ordinary. Off screen, the new mother is held to the first standard (desirable, unchanged) and punished with the language of the second (grotesque, “finished”) the moment she fails it.
Beauty, age and the gendered double standard
Ketu H. Katrak argues that women’s bodies are political terrain [9], and the Bollywood example makes that visible. Naomi Wolf’s The Beauty Myth describes beauty standards as a form of social control that tightens as women gain other kinds of freedom [10]. Laura Mulvey’s account of the male gaze explains who the standard serves: the woman is built to be looked at [11]. Motherhood and ageing arrive together to break the contract. Basu, now in her late forties, joked that ageing is treated as the biggest sin a woman can commit. The same cinema that allows its male stars to age into gravitas rarely extends the courtesy to its actresses.
It is also worth acknowledging what the criticism ignores. Basu told ELLE India that she took up weight training not for aesthetics but after doctors warned that an injury might end her ability to dance and perform action scenes [12]. Her fitness DVDs, which my mother and I danced to, were a response to a body in pain. The public rewrote that into a story about vanity, and then punished her when the vanity “failed”.
What has changed since 2012 is who answers back. When Aishwarya was attacked, defenders such as Kajol and Lara Dutta largely argued that she deserved time and privacy [3]. In 2026, the defences are more structural. Salman Khan used a Bigg Boss platform to say that weight gain after pregnancy is normal and that Katrina should be given time with her family, and a radio presenter who mocked her subsequently apologised [13]. The actor Ali Zafar urged men to examine the privilege that makes them feel entitled to grade a woman’s body [5]. Actresses including Shivaleeka Oberoi, Sonarika Bhadoria and Shraddha Arya have asked people to stop glorifying a version of motherhood that does not exist and to stop treating women as “before and after” pictures [14][15]. They are no longer simply defending one woman. They are naming the mechanism.
Claiming the change
Creed ends her argument with a possibility that classical horror rarely grants: a monstrous-feminine that speaks in her own voice and shapes her own destiny rather than serving as a warning. Contemporary horror made by women, such as Raw (2016) and Ginger Snaps (2000), gives its transforming women some claim over their transformation. In both films a young woman’s body changes in ways that frighten the people around her, and the story stays with her experience rather than their fear. Basu’s horror roles never did, because the possessed woman is exorcised and the femme fatale is punished.
The public conversation about motherhood has begun to move in the same direction. In 2012, Aishwarya’s defenders asked for time and privacy for her, which left the expectation of a recovery untouched. The voices of 2026 ask why a recovery is owed at all. Once the “before and after” picture is named as a mechanism rather than a verdict on one woman, it becomes harder to treat any woman’s body as a story with a deadline.

Her recent public life reads, almost by accident, like the missing third move. She has described the trolling as a deeply disturbing reflection of how society treats women, and said that another woman in her place might have been scarred by it [16]. Katrina Kaif, asked about beauty after her son’s birth, spoke about soothing her more reactive skin and about “looking my best” as being about feeling her best, without mentioning the trolls at all [17]. Neither woman stages the comeback the film industry expects, the glossy “return” story. Both are describing a body that has changed and declining to apologise for it.
If the maternal body unsettles us because it refuses to stay the same, then perhaps the most radical refusal of the gaze is not to become the monster or to “bounce back”, but to let the body change without apology. My mother, dumbbells in hand in a Colaba living room, understood that long before the trolls had a hashtag.
Bibliography
[1] Life.lk, ‘Aishwarya Rai Bachchan holds her head high in Cannes following baby weight criticisms’, Life.lk, (25 May 2012), <https://www.life.lk/article/style/aishwarya-rai-bachchan-holds-her-head-high-in-cannes-following-baby-weight-criticisms/53/1316>, {6 October 2026}.
[2] ABC News Radio, ‘Former Miss World Slammed Over Baby Fat’, ABC News, (May 2012), <https://www.eastidahonews.com/?p=30040>, {6 October 2026}.
[3] IBTimes UK, ‘Aishwarya Rai Bachchan Responds to Weight Gain Controversy, Says She is Enjoying Motherhood’, International Business Times UK, (May 2012), <https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/aishwarya-rai-bachchan-weight-gain-controversy-cannes-345950>, {6 October 2026}; ‘Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, Kajol defends Ash for post-baby weight gain’, IBTimes India, (2012), <https://www.ibtimes.co.in/aishwarya-rai-bachchan-kajol-defends-ash-for-post-baby-weight-gain-347168>, {6 October 2026}.
[4] Indiaforums, ‘Katrina Kaif trolled over postpartum look, Shivaleeka Oberoi hits back: “This is motherhood!”’, Indiaforums, (September 2026*), <https://www.indiaforums.com/article/katrina-kaif-trolled-over-postpartum-look-shivaleeka-oberoi-hits-back-this-is-motherhood_236005>, {6 October 2026}.
[5] Gulf News, ‘Pakistani actor Ali Zafar defends Katrina Kaif after post-pregnancy trolling, urges men to “correct themselves”’, Gulf News, (September 2026*), <https://gulfnews.com/amp/story/entertainment%2Fpakistani-actor-ali-zafar-defends-katrina-kaif-after-post-pregnancy-trolling-urges-men-to-correct-themselves-1.500677663>, {6 October 2026}.
[6] Free Press Journal, ‘Bipasha Basu Recalls Brutal Body-Shaming After Daughter Devi’s Birth’, Free Press Journal, (5 September 2026), <https://www.freepressjournal.in/entertainment/bipasha-basu-recalls-brutal-body-shaming-after-daughter-devis-birth-insensitive-paps-took-bizarre-photos-of-me>, {6 October 2026}; Gulf News, ‘Bipasha Basu on starting Bollywood’s muscle trend, and the injury behind it’, Gulf News, (2026*), <https://gulfnews.com/entertainment/bipasha-basu-on-starting-bollywoods-muscle-trend-and-the-injury-behind-it-1.500666193>, {6 October 2026}.
[7] Barbara Creed, The Monstrous-Feminine: Film, Feminism, Psychoanalysis (London: Routledge, 1993; 2007 edition), <https://ieas-szeged.hu/downtherabbithole/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Barbara-Creed-The-Monstrous-Feminine-2007.pdf>, {6 October 2026}.
[8] Julia Kristeva, Powers of Horror: An Essay on Abjection, trans. Leon S. Roudiez (New York: Columbia University Press, 1982).
[9] Ketu H. Katrak, Politics of the Female Body: Postcolonial Women Writers of the Third World (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 2006).
[10] Naomi Wolf, The Beauty Myth: How Images of Beauty Are Used Against Women (London: Chatto & Windus, 1990).
[11] Laura Mulvey, ‘Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema’, Screen, 16:3 (1975), pp. 6–18.
[12] Gulf News, ‘Bipasha Basu on starting Bollywood’s muscle trend, and the injury behind it’ (see [6]).
[13] Gulf News, ‘Pakistani RJ who body-shamed Katrina Kaif apologises: “I am really sorry”’, Gulf News, (September 2026*), <https://gulfnews.com/entertainment/pakistani-rj-who-body-shamed-katrina-kaif-apologises-i-am-really-sorry-1.500683215>, {6 October 2026}.
[14] Observer Online Report, ‘Katrina Kaif body-shamed, Shivalika Oberoi defends her’, The Observer (Dhaka), (3 September 2026), <https://www.observerbd.com/news/591451>, {6 October 2026}.
[15] The Bridge Chronicle, ‘Sonarika Bhadoria Calls Out Katrina Kaif’s Postpartum Trollers’, The Bridge Chronicle, (September 2026*), <https://www.thebridgechronicle.com/lifestyle/entertainment/sonarika-bhadoria-defends-katrina-kaif-postpartum-trolling>, {6 October 2026}.
[16] Madhyamam, ‘Bipasha Basu slams trolls for fat-shaming her post-pregnancy’, Madhyamam, (2026*), <https://madhyamamonline.com/amp/entertainment/bipasha-basu-slams-trolls-for-fat-shaming-her-post-pregnancy-1418431>, {6 October 2026}.
[17] Gulf News, ‘Katrina Kaif opens up on post-pregnancy and motherhood: “Looking my best is now about feeling my best”’, Gulf News, (September 2026*), <https://gulfnews.com/entertainment/katrina-kaif-opens-up-on-post-pregnancy-looking-my-best-is-now-about-feeling-my-best-1.500682388>, {6 October 2026}.




Comments